Legal Opinion: Tinker v Des Moines Independent Community School District In 1965 a group and parents in Des Moines met and decided that they wanted to do something in protest against the Vietnam War. It was decided that students should wear black armbands signalling their protest at school. Learning of this decision, school officials responded by implementing a ban on the wearing of black armbands. Students wearing the armband would be asked to remove them and should they refuse to do so, they would be suspended. Two Tinker siblings and another student (Petitioners) wore black armbands and upon being asked to remove them, refused and were subsequently suspended. The three students filed a complaint against the Des Moines Independent Community School District (Respondent) in a Federal court claiming violation of their First Amendment Right to Free expression. That suit failed and the petitioners eventually appealed to the US Supreme Court. The petitioners invoked the First Amendment to the US Constitution which essentially protects freedom of speech, freedom of religion, freedom of peaceful assembly and the right to “ petition the Government for a redress of grievances” (US Constitution, First Amendment). The main question in the Tinker Case was therefore whether or not the wearing of an armband constituted speech and if so, whether or not banning the wearing of armbands amounted to a violation of free expression/speech pursuant to the First Amendment of the US Constitution. The petitioners argued that wearing armbands was a protected First Amendment right in that it constituted expression of an opinion. The wearing of armbands in the manner conducted by the petitioners was essentially passive speech, caused no disturbance in the school’s learning and social environment and did not infringe upon the rights of others. Thus the school’s disciplinary action was unreasonable and infringed the petitioners’ constitutionally protected right to freedom of expression pursuant to the First Amendment of the US Constitution. The respondent argued that there was a reasonable fear or apprehension that the wearing of armbands would cause disruption in the school’s learning and social environment. The respondent argued that the implementation of the ban against the wearing of the armbands was necessary to prevent disturbances at the school. While this argument had been accepted by the lower courts, the US Supreme Court rejected this argument ruling that there was no evidence supporting the fear of disturbance and schools could not infringe student’s First Amendment rights on the basis of unsubstantiated fears or apprehensions of disturbances or disruptions in the school’s learning and social environment. The US Supreme Court’s ruling in the Tinker case is referred to as the Tinker standard (Lavarias, 2008). The ruling represents a balancing between two conflicting realities. First, there is the idea that children of school age are just as capable as adults in terms of forming and expressing opinions on sensitive issues and thus should be accorded First Amendment rights to free expression. Secondly, there is also an appreciation of the fact that schools are places for learning and all efforts should be made to safeguard against the risk of hate speech and other modes of free expression that can disrupt the school environment. In this regard, the Tinker standard successfully balances the school’s interest in restricting free speech and the students’ interest in exercising free speech of expression (Starrett, 2009). I agree with the Tinker ruling since the school children’s protest was decidedly passive and was not conducted in a way that would or did disrupt the school environment. If children come to school and express opinions in a way that would from the perspective of a reasonable observer likely cause a disturbance or does cause a disturbance, freedom of expression should therefore be restricted, but only in those specific circumstances. Bibliography Lavarias, J. “ A Re-examination of the Tinker Standard: Freedom of Speech in Public Schools.” Hastings Constitutional Law Quarterly, (Spring 2008) Vol. 35(3): 575-598. Starrett, B. “ Tinker’s Facebook Profile: A New Test for Protesting Student Cyber Speech.” Virginia Journal of Law & Technology, (Fall 2009) Vol. 14(212): 213-254. Tinker v Des Moines Independent Community School District 393 US 503 (1969). US Constitution.
Related papers
L’oreal: building its empire in indonesia through its luxury brand, lancme
Objective: This strategy for marketing whitening products manufactured by L'Oreal is selected because this particular cosmetics' giant is a world leader in such products, and local manufacturing allows for easy placement of the products in the market. The bundled product ...
Make a title
The US government offered security to the settlers, who quickly established homes in the midst of native tribes. Both the white settlers and the US government were irrational.
Born on the 4th of july
The film Born on the 4th of July, by the renowned director Oliver Stone is interconnected with the war history and the relationship between America and Vietnam. The director tries to unveil the futility of war, the psychological trauma created ...
Martin luther king theory: issue of power essay
Martin Luther is a prominent leader who used non-violent approaches of fighting for peoples civil rights in the United States and other countries in the worlds. The letter teaches people of faith that they should use peaceful means in demanding ...
A look at muslim empires
The Muslim community is known to have been under the influence of three major empires: the Ottoman Empire, The Safavids and the Grandeur of the Mughals. The expansionist policies of the Ottoman Empire were not undertaken with the aim of ...
Expressive ballet: revolutionary dance style
Expressionism has been a great thing for Australian dance, and it is a miracle that Diaghilev brought it around to influence us, because it can draw audiences into the feel and emotion of dance, and to leave them with a ...
Oral communication process essay
Interpersonal Communication Interpersonal communication is usually defined by communication scholars in numerous ways, usually describing participants who are dependent upon one another and have a shared history. Successful interpersonal communication assumes that both the message senders and the message receivers ...
Aarp (outline)
The founder Ethel Percy Andrus formed the group in order to assist the elderly population in the US to remain active both physically and intellectually, in order to improve the quality of elderly people's lives. The organization targets members of ...
The industrial revolution: newspaperassignment assignment
The spinning factories require a humid and warm atmosphere to be able to function properly, steam engines contribute to the heat in the factory and the children have to work through long days in these uncomfortable hot conditions. The treatment ...
What role did sport play during the cold war? assignment
Stalin believed that his country would be viewed as the strongest country if his athletes were the strongest as well, as " in the arms race it was thought that the one with the biggest, strongest weapons would be viewed ...
Women lives during world war i era
Women Lives during World War I Era The coming of the World War 11 and the Roaring Twenties, a term associated in referenceto the 1920s in the U. In the 1920s and toward the coming of the WWII, urbanization was ...
Should the war have been fought us or south vietnam
Many accounts and conclusions about the war in Vietnam are told through the eyes of the North Vietnamese, the South Vietnamese, the United States military soldiers, power figureheads of the involved countries, as well as views from around the world. ...
Draft dodgers during the vietnam war. assignment
Instead of the United States draft dodgers, some Canadians join the United States military to fight. The peace movement was a great factor in the number of draft dodgers.
Italy profolio
Legislative Branch of Government in Italy The legislature is composed of the lower house, which is the chamber of deputies and the upper house comprising of senate. The Executive Branch of Government in Italy This is composed of the President, ...
The progression of african americans from 1865 to 1920
The blacks also ran out of labor in the South and choose to migrate to the North were there was an abundance of jobs. The Niagara Movement was thought to be more radical than that of the NAACP.
What has been the thinking of scholars on beard’s thesis 100 years later
Beard's Thesis 100 Years Later For the first century of the United s' history, history scholars admired the work of the founding fathers. However, a hundred years after 1913, Charles Beard's argument became the most widespread explanation and justification of ...
The oppressive legislature and the actions of the british
Choosing Sides The oppressive legislature and the actions of the British brought the colonies of America together against their common enemy. For the citizen in the states at the time it was, very likely, an extremely difficult decision to ...
Old english era
The Anglo-Saxon period is the oldest known period of time that had a complex culture with stable government, art, and a fairly large amount of literature. The Angles joined the Saxons in the invasion of Britain in the fifth and ...
The context of india 1757 1857 history essay
These two components were considered unclean and the majority of soldiers in the Sepoy Army refused to use them.[2]The spark provided by the cartridges was clearly a short term issue, as initially, the Sepoys had rejoiced in the advantage that ...
Industrial revolution dbq assignment
This document shows the male of view of working women. This document shows the idea of disrespect of women independence and the stunting of it.
Justice process assignment
The custodial model based on the assumption that prisoners have been incarcerated for the protection of society and emphasizes security, discipline, and order subordinating the prisoner to the authority of the warden. State Prison Systems -94% of offenders are held ...
Australian gold rush assignment
The primary consequence and gain of the gold rushes was the growth of population due to migration. From late 1852 the gold fields became a montage of nationalities, and thus there was ' a marked tendency to segregate in national ...
The issues in the preamble to the constitution of 1787
How did the events of the first three decades of the American Republic reflect the issues enumerated in the Preamble to the Constitution of 1787? Name: Professor: Course: Date: How did the events of the first three decades of the ...
Roman empire and abbasid…idk.
Although the fall of the Roman Empire and the Abbasids differed greatly they both still declined due to internal and external factors, such as the government and economy failing, foreign invaders, and reasons caused by the people. The political confusion ...
History 4th week
[Due History 4th Week Question The four most important points made by Holliday are: the history of gold mining; its evolution, especially in terms of equipment; challenges and issues related to gold mining; and the future of the industry. Question ...